Join our newsletter today and receive a special 10% discount code for your next purchase.
The short answer
A solitaire setting is chosen first by how the ring will be worn, then by how much of the stone you want to see. Prongs let the most light reach the diamond; a bezel wraps it in metal and leaves almost nothing to catch. Prong count, metal and the underside of the setting decide the rest.
- Start with the hand, not the photograph. Desk work and workshop work need different protection.
- Prongs show more of the stone and need checking; a bezel is the smoother, more enclosed choice.
- Four claws suit a round stone; six add contact points and suit some fancy shapes.
- Platinum's claws flatten rather than wear thin, and 9ct gold is harder than 18ct.
- The underside of the setting decides whether a wedding band will sit flush.
Start with how you will wear the ring
Most people arrive with a feeling about the ring, not a specification. The setting is where that feeling meets daily life. Before you look at a single claw or bezel, think about how the ring will spend its days: typing, gardening, lifting children, working with your hands.
We start every consultation with this question. A ring worn at a desk and a ring worn in a workshop need different protection. Ask yourself whether the ring will catch on jumpers and bags, and how often you will take it off.
- Desk work and light daily wear suit most settings.
- Physical work or sport favours a lower, closer setting.
- Frequent handwashing means a setting that traps less dirt underneath.
Prong setting vs bezel setting
A prong setting holds the centre stone with small metal claws that rise above its surface. A bezel setting surrounds the stone with a continuous rim of metal that follows its edge. The difference shapes light, security and wear.
Our Solitaire With Full Bezel Setting And Plain Shank wraps the girdle of the centre stone on a slim plain band, with no prongs above it. You can see the whole range of engagement rings alongside it.
Prong or bezel: the trade-offs
| Setting | Strengths | Trade-offs |
|---|---|---|
| Prong | Lets the most light reach the stone; open, airy look | Claws can snag and need periodic checks |
| Bezel | Smooth profile, secure, little to catch | Covers more of the stone's edge, so it looks less open |
Choose prongs if you want the stone to appear as large and bright as possible. Choose a bezel if the ring will meet a lot of wear and you want fewer snags.
Four claws or six?
Prong count changes how the stone is held. Four claws are a common choice for a round stone, and they leave more of it visible. Six claws add contact points, which some people prefer for fancy shapes, because the load is spread across more of the stone's edge.
Our Solitaire With Six-Claw Basket sets the stone in a six-claw basket above the band. Our Solitaire With Plain Cathedral Shank sets it above a plain polished cathedral shank, where the shoulders rise to meet the setting.
Choosing your metal
Metal is not only a colour decision. The claws that hold your stone are only as reliable as the metal they are drawn from. A claw is a thin, load-bearing piece of metal: bent, filed and polished during setting, then asked to hold its shape for years of knocks.
Platinum is denser than gold, and that density is why its claws behave differently. They displace and flatten rather than thinning away. Gold comes in different alloys, and the carat changes both the colour and the hardness of the metal.
How metal choice changes claw security over the years
| Metal | Hardness in wear | How claws behave over time | Best suited to |
|---|---|---|---|
| 950 platinum | Dense; displaces on impact | Flatten rather than wear thin; often dressed back | Daily-wear prong settings, high-set stones |
| 18ct gold | Softer surface | Wear and thin; re-tipping more likely over time | Bezels, low-set stones, occasional wear |
| 9ct gold | Harder, more scratch-resistant | Hold their shape well, less forgiving if bent | Active wearers who want a gold colour |
| White gold (plated) | As per the alloy beneath | As per the alloy, plus a plating refresh | Anyone wanting a bright white look |
If you are unsure which metal suits the setting you have in mind, our bespoke design service lets you see the combination drawn up before anything is made. Our jewellery repair service is where existing claws come for checking and re-tipping.
Planning for the band you will wear with it
The wedding band decision is made twice: once when you choose the engagement ring, and again when the band arrives and does not sit the way you pictured. The cause is almost always the underside of the setting. A band can only sit flush against the engagement ring if the metal beneath the centre stone leaves room for it.
Picture the profile from the side. Settings differ in shape underneath, and that is what decides how much flat surface a band has to sit against.
Which settings sit flush with a plain band
| Setting style | Underside profile | Flush fit with a plain band | What usually works |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plain shank solitaire | Open under the basket | Usually close, sometimes a small gap | Plain band, or a shallow curve |
| Cathedral shank solitaire | Shoulders rise into the stone | Often a visible gap | Shaped band, cut to follow the shoulders |
| Bezel set solitaire | Low, continuous rim | Closest fit of the three | Plain band sits neatly against the rim |
| Six-claw basket solitaire | Basket sits proud of the band | Depends on how deep the basket is | Shaped band, or a band worn on the other hand |
How to check the fit before you commit
- Ask to see the engagement ring and a plain band together on your hand, not separately on a tray.
- Look at the gap from the side, at eye level, with your hand relaxed rather than splayed.
- Slide the band against the engagement ring and check whether the two metals touch at one point or along a line.
Watch out
Point contact is what causes rubbing and wear. If the two rings meet at a single point, that is where the metal will go. A band shaped to follow the setting spreads the contact along a line instead.
If you already own the engagement ring and are choosing the band afterwards, bring it with you to our wedding rings and bespoke bands service. If the ring is still being designed, you can build it through our engagement ring studio and see how it sits before anything is made.
Which of our solitaire settings to try first
| Setting | What it is | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Solitaire With Full Bezel Setting And Plain Shank | A continuous rim of metal around the stone, on a slim plain band | Daily wear, fewer snags |
| Solitaire With Six-Claw Basket | Six claws rising from an open basket | A more enclosed hold on a fancy shape |
| Solitaire With Plain Shank | The stone set above a plain, unadorned band | A clean band that pairs easily with a wedding ring |
| Solitaire With Plain Cathedral Shank | Shoulders that sweep up into the setting | A classic, high-shouldered look |
All four are made in 9ct, 18ct and 14K gold or 950 platinum, and all of them start from the same choice: how much of the stone you want to see, and what the ring has to survive.
Book a consultation to try the settings on
Reading about settings only goes so far. Seeing a ring on your own hand tells you more, because the proportion of stone to hand is the part nobody can describe to you. You can visit our showroom in Chichester, arrange a home visit, or consult with us remotely, with no obligation to buy.
To see how a setting suits you, book a private consultation. If you already own a ring you want to adapt, our remodelling service can reset it.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best setting for a solitaire engagement ring?
There is no single best one. A prong setting shows the most of the stone and suits someone who does not mind having the claws checked; a bezel is the calmer choice for a ring that will meet a lot of wear. Which one is right depends on your hands and your working day.
Which solitaire setting is most secure?
A bezel, because the rim of metal covers the stone's edge and there is nothing standing up to catch. A well-made prong setting is secure too, and it is the claws rather than the stone that need looking at over the years.
Can a wedding band sit flush against a solitaire?
Often, but it depends on the underside of the setting and on the shape of the band. A bezel with a low rim usually lets a plain band sit close, while a cathedral shank or a deep basket can leave a gap that a shaped band closes.
Should I choose platinum or gold for a prong setting?
Platinum's claws flatten rather than wear thin, which is why it is often chosen for a high-set stone worn every day. 9ct gold is harder than 18ct and holds its shape well, though it is less forgiving if a claw is bent.
Tell us what you have in mind and we will go through the settings with you in Chichester, at home, or over a video call. More of our guides are collected on the fine jewellery blog and guides page.
Related posts
Build your engagement ring online: choose the setting, the metal, the diamond and the size, then see it in 3D before anything is made.
The three stone engagement ring: the past, present and future reading, how the three stones are balanced, and why the centre leads the eye.
Book a custom ring design consultation at Griffin & Co.
Halo or solitaire? How each setting sits on the hand, how they wear day to day, how they meet a wedding band, and how to choose.
Asymmetry, mixed metals, toi et moi and coloured stones — how a genuinely one-off engagement ring gets designed and made.
How to identify Art Deco, Edwardian and Victorian rings, what to check before buying antique, and when to recreate rather than restore.
Why sapphire works as an engagement stone, the colours beyond blue, and the settings that protect it — a bespoke jeweller's guide.
How yellow, white and rose gold differ in wear, maintenance and how they flatter a diamond, from a goldsmith's bench in Chichester.
Every engagement ring tells a love story, but have you ever wondered about the story behind its creation? That carefully...
Every love story is unique, so why should the ring that symbolises yours look exactly like everyone else's? Off-the-shelf designs...
Finding the perfect engagement ring no longer means spending hours wandering from jeweller to jeweller, hoping something on the shelf...
Bigger isn't always better. Carat is the most famous C, but it's also the most misunderstood. It's a measure of weight, not visual size. A poorly cut 1.0-carat diamond can look dull and visually smaller than a masterfully cut 0.95-carat stone. Before you get fixed on a 'magic number,' read our guide to balancing carat with true craftsmanship.
Perfection isn't about being 'Flawless'—it's about being 'eye-clean.' Nearly all diamonds have natural 'birthmarks,' but most are invisible to the naked eye. In this post, our experts explain the GIA Clarity scale and share the inside secret to finding a breathtaking diamond (often at a VS or SI grade) that offers incredible value without compromising on beauty.
When it comes to diamond colour, 'D' isn't the only answer. The GIA's D-to-Z scale grades the absence of colour, but the secret to finding the best value lies in how you set your stone. Did you know a yellow gold band can make a G-colour diamond look just as icy as a D? We decode the 'sweet spot' for your bespoke platinum or gold ring.
What is the most important C for your engagement ring? It's not what you think. While many focus on size, a diamond's Cut is the true engine of its sparkle, fire, and brilliance. A large, colourless diamond can appear dull and lifeless if it has a poor cut. Before you start your bespoke journey, learn why our Griffin & Co. jewellers believe you should never compromise on Cut.
Discover why more couples are choosing lab grown diamond engagement rings for their perfect blend of ethical sourcing, environmental responsibility, and exceptional value. In this guide, you’ll learn how these cultured gems are created, why they stand apart as conflict-free alternatives, how to evaluate their quality using the 4Cs, and which shapes and settings flatter them best. Whether you’re seeking an eco-friendly choice or exceptional value, this roadmap will steer you confidently to your forever ring.
Imagine a ring that tells your unique love story, crafted exclusively for you. This complete guide to bespoke engagement rings in the UK uncovers the entire creation process, from initial consultation to hand-finished heirloom. Discover how to select the perfect diamond or gemstone, explore popular settings and 2025 trends, and learn what factors shape cost and style, empowering you to transform your vision into a one-of-a-kind symbol of commitment.